Cardinals Should Chase Casey Schmitt Despite His Flaws

More Stories

Cardinals Should Chase Casey Schmitt Despite His Flaws

The Giants want to trade Casey Schmitt. Per Redbird Rants, his stats show a massive walk rate issue, but the Cardinals have the coaching fix.

Adam Jecho Cleared For Return After Program Stint

Blues prospect Adam Jecho is cleared to return from the NHL/NHLPA Player Assistance Program and assigned to Springfield Thunderbirds.

Blues’ Top Line And Summer Trades Fail To Deliver Wins

St. Louis Blues fans face three hard truths this season: a top line that can't score, summer trades that fizzled, and a backup goalie who can't play.

Blues Shuffle Lines As McTavish Faces Former Team Anaheim

St. Louis Blues mix up their forward lines for Tuesday's game against the Anaheim Ducks, with Mason McTavish set to face his old squad.

Mason McTavish Seeks Revenge As Blues Face Ducks Tuesday

Mason McTavish returns to Anaheim with a chip on his shoulder. Two Blues X-factors could decide Tuesday night's game against a surging Ducks squad.

The St. Louis Cardinals need to stop waiting and start making calls. The San Francisco Giants have reportedly opened the door for offers on 27-year-old Casey Schmitt, and this is the exact type of deal the front office should be chasing. Schmitt broke out in 2026 with a .271 batting average and a .784 OPS while hitting 21 home runs. He proved he can handle third base, posting five outs above average at the hot corner. That defensive skill is exactly what the Cardinals lack right now.

A Flawed Profile With High Upside

Schmitt is not a perfect player, and that is why the price might be low. Many scouts were frightened by his significant deficit in plate discipline. According to Redbird Rants, Schmitt had a major league-low walk rate of just 2.7% among hitters with at least 400 plate appearances. This number looks like a disaster for 2027 if pitchers figure him out. The Giants had the worst walk rate in the league last season, which suggests a team-wide approach rather than a permanent flaw in Schmitt’s game. With the right help, he could rebound to his 7.8% walk rate from 2025.

The Trade Cost and The Fit

The Giants need rotation help, and the Cardinals have the right piece to swap. Both clubs might be satisfied by a one-for-one exchange of pitcher Michael McGreevy for Casey Schmitt. This move makes sense because the Giants have Matt Chapman entrenched at third base and Willy Adames at shortstop. They simply do not have a spot for Schmitt to play every day. The Cardinals, on the other hand, are looking for a long-term answer at third base rather than a shortstop fix. Redbird Rants notes that while the team is reportedly interested in a stopgap solution, Schmitt offers a much better path forward. The front office might even consider moving Jesús Báez to shortstop once he reaches the majors to clear the way.

Chaim Bloom seems less focused on defense than manager Oli Marmol, which opens the door for a trade that sacrifices some middle infield skill for more power.

Add Gameday STL as a preferred source on Google

Dallin Ballard
Dallin Ballard
Dallin Ballard is a contributor to the GameDay Network.

Subscribe

- Never miss a story with notifications

Latest stories